Archive for November, 2015

Britain at War 1939-1945 in Ace Reviews

November 14, 2015
Second edition

Second edition

You can see this at http://acereviews.mail-chute.com/?p=439.

Book Review: Britain at War 1939-1945 by James Lingard

Buy it on Amazon (Kindle) Buy it on Amazon (Paperback) Buy it on Apple (iBook)

– Four Stars

[Further information about the book is available at http://bratwar.simplesite.com%5D

Synopsis

I just finished reading Britain at War 1939-1945 by James Lingard.  Britain at War is a chronological story of the major events that occurred during World War II, interspersed with the author’s, and other personal eye witness accounts of those events, affecting Britain — during those years.

The text introduces the reader to the state and effectiveness of the British RAF, German Luftwaffe, British Navy, German U-Boats, E-Boats, and ground offensives.  Interesting reading includes informative facts of the high number of civilian casualties resulting from German bombings in London as well as the major campaigns against the Germans at major fronts in North Africa, India, Italy, Poland and France.

Personal stories are included in the text describing Lingard’s experience as a young boy in Britain, one of which was learning that the shelter his family lived in had been destroyed by German bombs while they were luckily away at the time.  Another interesting personal story includes relocating to the South Britain coast with his family for safety that was believed to be less interest to German bombers that ended up being surprisingly bombed by a few of the German Luftwaffe forcing their departure from the location.

Other interesting reading describes the V1 and V2 bombs the Germans developed towards the end of the war used on Britain while at the same time the Americans had developed their atom bomb that would eventually be dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki to end the war against Japan.  The text also gives interesting facts surrounding the build-up of 1.5 million American soldiers in Britain prior to the famous D-Day invasion, the 150,000 man offensive, 10,000 man casualty, the Allies put forth on D-Day to famously successfully storm the beaches of Normandy.

Strengths

Much is written about World War II.  A lot of what is written are lengthy texts containing mostly facts and dates surrounding the war.  What I like about Britain at War is the text is not too exhaustive but gives a chronological, succinct account of the major events of the war.  Strategies of both the Axis and Allies are given brief attention and how they succeeded or failed, which I liked.  The book I find to be a good overview of what transpired in a shorter text form while covering the major events.

Another strength of the book compared to other wartime books published is the personal accounts of the author while living through the war described.  These add a unique human element to the book that gives the reader a sense of realness to the war and how it affected real every-day people, in particular this family in Britain living through the German air bombings.

Finally, the facts that were conveyed in the book I felt were not too over done to overwhelm and bore the reader.  I liked that attention was given to the number of soldiers involved in various campaigns on both the Allies and Axis, casualties suffered, and interesting facts about the British RAF Spitfires and Hurricanes, German Luftwaffe, naval destroyers, U-boats, E-boats, etc., as well as explanation of military strategy from both the Axis and Allies perspective described.

Weaknesses

The book was well-edited.  I didn’t encounter grammatical or spelling errors.  The book was put together well, one chapter building on the other chronologically from 1939-1945 as the title conveys, so I cannot say that editing was a weakness.

What I would have liked maybe from the book is more personal stories.  I think the commonly known war campaigns and facts may have outdone the personal stories as far as balance in the book goes.

Significant personal stories worth mentioning may have been limited to the author but maybe more other primary accounts heard from neighbours, friends or relatives and how their lives were affected as well during the time would give the book the additional human touch.  Much attention is given to the actual war itself throughout the world than simply what was actually going on day-to-day in Britain.

Conclusion

Britain at War is a terrific book covering the chronological major events of World War II from a Brit’s perspective.  The book contains coverage of wartime facts, military strategy from Axis and Allies, a quote per chapter from Churchill, Britain’s leader during the war, descriptions and effectiveness of various military weapons used during the war, as well as personal stories from the author himself having lived through the bombings in England by the German Luftwaffe and, gladly, avoiding a ground invasion from Germany of Britain all together.

The book flows well in its chronological account of the major events of the war.  The personal stories keep the book personable and the facts conveyed about the major events of the war were not overdone to bore the reader and make a stale book.  It’s also a concisely written book that leaves the reader with a good survey of the major events of the years 1939-1945 worldwide as well as in Britain itself.  I give Britain at War 1939-1945, 4 stars.

New 5 star review by Don Slone

November 1, 2015

Britain at War 1939 to 1945 By James Lingard

war2

“Who cares about Poland? Where is it, anyway? What is to become of us?”

So exclaims author James Lingard’s mother at the beginning of the murderous world conflict that would ultimately claim millions of lives on both sides of the Atlantic and indeed, from both allies and foes alike.

As a young boy in Britain during the critical war years of 1939 through 1945, Lingard and his mother and father endured many hardships and constantly lived in peril, as did all of the U.K.’s citizenry. This is his excellent story, well-researched for historical accuracy, but highly personalized to maintain the interest of even the most casual reader.

Recalling his first air raid, Lingard tells us the first words of an air raid warden, who had been looking for them while they huddled in a nearby wood — survivors of a picnic dangerously interrupted:

“I was about to say you should have been in your shelter. But the shelter received a direct hit. There’s no trace of it. Just a huge crater. You’d all have been blown to smithereens.”

It is war’s capriciousness in dealing out life and death that the author documents so eloquently in this book. Bombs fall in regular and terrifying numbers. The nation’s leaders come dangerously close to making disastrous decisions. And the stalwart British people do what they must to survive yet another day.

On a trip to the shore, Lingard waves happily to a low-flying airplane. Its German pilot waves back. And the small boy narrowly escapes arrest as a spy.

Lingard’s mother frequently listens to the wireless for war news, but is often more captivated by music such as “Run Rabbit Run,” played at a fast tempo to speed up production in the factories.

“We still had no effective answer to the German might. Hitler’s bombers continued to harass us, and he tried his utmost to starve us into submission. In the period May to December, 1940, the enemy sank 745 merchant vessels with a gross tonnage of over three million tons. On 17th to 19th October, German U-boats sank 33 ships, twenty of which were in one convoy . . .”

It is this very attention to detail — combined with the book’s inherent human interest — that elevates it above so many books about World War Two. For me personally, it put a very real face on a dark period in civilized history — a period which I, like so many others of my Baby Boomer generation, only experience through watching dry documentaries on The History Channel.

How refreshing, then, to have this warm and intimate look inside a great nation’s stalwart struggle against almost insurmountable odds — and to rejoice with the author at its ultimate survival.

Five stars to Britain at War, and a hearty recommendation to librarians everywhere to acquire a copy so future generations can become enlightened.

Amazon Link


%d bloggers like this: